CHAPTER XXXVI: CHRIST'S THREEFOLD VICTORY PRELIMINARY REMARKS

[2095] Luke 22:15

[2096] Ibid., 22:16f.

[2097] John 14:31.

[2098] Ibid., 15:13

[2099] Ibid., 17:17, 20.

[2100] cf. IIIa, q. 7, a. 9-13

[2101] Christ willed that certain martyrs at the moment of their martyrdom should experience the greatest joy that would lessen the pain, as in the case of St. Lawrence, St. Ignatius of Antioch, and St. Andrew: but Christ Himself willed to experience "sorrow even unto death" (Matt. 26:38) so that His sacrifice might be more perfect and meritorious.

[2102] Matt. 26:38

[2103] Mark 14:33

[2104] cf. Louis Chardon, O.P., La Croix de Jesus, chap. 5, wherein he says: "The plenitude of grace that belongs properly to Jesus, as head of His mystical body, causes in His soul a desire for the cross, " (pp. 46-52).

[2105] cf. IIIa, q. 46, a. 5, 6

[2106] Ibid., q. 14, a. 4.

[2107] Ibid., q. 46, a. 6.

[2108] Lam. 1:12

[2109] cf. IIIa, q. 46, a. 6, first reason

[2110] Ibid., second reason.

[2111] Ibid., fourth reason

[2112] Isa. 53:4

[2113] Luke 22:42

[2114] cf. IIIa, q. 84, a. 9; q. 85, a. 1

[2115] Isa. 53:4

[2116] I Pet. 2:24.

[2117] I John 3:5

[2118] John 3:30

[2119] cf. IIIa, q. 46, a. 7, 8

[2120] Ibid., q. 9, a. 2.

[2121] John 3:11.

[2122] Ibid., 3:31f.

[2123] Ibid., 3:13.

[2124] Ibid., 17:24

[2125] Denz., no. 2183

[2126] cf. IIIa, q. 9, a. 2; q. 10.

[2127] Denz., no. 224

[2128] cf. IIIa, q. 9, a. 3

[2129] Luke 23:34

[2130] Ibid., 23:43

[2131] John 19:36f.

[2132] Matt. 27:46

[2133] John 19:28.

[2134] Ibid., 19:30

[2135] Luke 23:46

[2136] John 19:30

[2137] Acts 7:55.

[2138] Clypeus theol., de Incarn., disp. XVI, a. 1, solv. obj., no. 14.

[2139] Summa theol., Ia IIae, q. 10, a. 2; see also Ibid., q. 5, a. 4.

[2140] Ibid., IIIa, q. 46, a. 8 ad 1.

[2141] John 14:27.

[2142] Ibid. 16:33.

[2143] cf. IIa, IIae, q. 28, 29

[2144] Denz., no. 1796

[2145] Matt. 26:38

[2146] John 19:30

[2147] Luke 23:46.

[2148] Matt. 27:46

[2149] Ps. 21:5f.

[2150] Gal. 3:13

[2151] John 19 30.

[2152] Luke 23:46

[2153] See p. 785

[2154] John 19 30

[2155] Ibid., 16:33

[2156] Luke 23:46

[2157] cf. IIIa, q. 47, a. 3

[2158] Rom. 8:32

[2159] Isa. 53:6, 10.

[2160] Com. in IIIam, d. 16, q. 1, a. 2

[2161] Loc. cit.

[2162] cf. IIIa, q. 46, a. 8

[2163] Com. in IIIam, q. 46, a. 8.

[2164] See p. 783

[2165] Clypeus theol., disp. 16, a. 1, no. 14

[2166] cf. IIIa, q. 46, a. 7; also q. 9, a. 2. See also Salmanticenses, Gonet, and Cajetan in their commentaries on these articles.

[2167] cf. IIIa, q. 46, a. 8, 1st obj. See also Aristotle's Ethics, Bk. XIV, chap. 4

[2168] 1st obj

[2169] De fide orthod., Bk. III, chap. 15

[2170] cf. IIIa, q. 46, a. 8

[2171] Ibid., a. 8, c.

[2172] Ibid., a. 6, ad 4

[2173] cf. De veritate, q. 26, a. 9, ad 7; Compend. theol., chap. 232. He had said in De veritate, q. 26, a. 9, ad 7: "The rational will regarded Christ's passion only as it concerned eternal truths, and according to these the will rejoiced in the Passion inasmuch as it was pleasing to God." See also Quodl. VII, a. 5, and III Sent., d. 15, q. 2, a. 1; q. 3, a. 3, q. 2. Also in Compend. theol., chap. 232, he said: "Christ's soul enjoyed the perfect vision of God. Therefore in the rational will of Christ's soul, whose particular function... is to contemplate and take counsel concerning eternal truths, there was nothing adverse or repugnant therein, which would give rise to any suffering detrimental to it.... Christ suffered sadness inasmuch as He knew there was imminent danger of guilt or punishment for those whom He loved because of His charity. Hence He grieved not only for Himself, but also for others. And because the love of one's neighbor belongs in a certain way to the higher reason, inasmuch as one's neighbor from charity is loved for God's sake, yet Christ's higher reason could not feel sad about the defects of His neighbors as it is possible for us to be sad. Because Christ's higher reason fully enjoyed the beatific vision, and so He apprehended that whatever pertains to the defects of others, inasmuch as this is included in divine wisdom, is fittingly ordained for some purpose, and inasmuch as anyone is permitted to sin and will be punished for the sin. Therefore neither Christ's soul, nor the souls of any of the blessed, who see God, can feel sad about the defects of others here on earth. But such is not the case with wayfarers, who as yet do not see the purpose of divine wisdom. These also according to the rational will are saddened at the defects of others, when they think that it belongs to God's honor and the exaltation of the faith, that some be saved, who nevertheless will be lost. Thus, therefore, such a person grieves according to the senses, imagination, and sensitive will for those who will be lost, but rejoices according to the rational will, inasmuch as these defects are referred to the ordering of divine wisdom. Therefore it could happen that Christ's sensitive will shrank from something that His rational will desired; yet there was no contrariety of appetites in Him, or rebellion of the flesh against the spirit..., but Christ permitted each of His lower faculties to be moved in its own way, as was becoming to Him."

[2174] Summa theol., IIIa, q. 46, a. 7, c. and ad 2

[2175] Com. in IIIam, q. 46, a. 7, no. 6.

[2176] Summa theol., Ia, q. 113, a. 7

[2177] Com. in IIIam, loc. cit.

[2178] De veritate, q. 26, a. 9, ad 7; Compend. theol., chap. 232.

[2179] St. Thomas says: "Angels do not grieve, either for sin or for the pains inflicted on men. For grief and sorrow, according to St. Augustine, are for those things which occur against our will. But nothing happens in the world contrary to the will of the angels and the other blessed, because their will cleaves entirely to the ordering of divine justice; while nothing happens in the world except what is effected or permitted by divine justice. Therefore, simply speaking, nothing occurs in the world against the will of the blessed.... Therefore, universally and absolutely speaking, the angels do not will sin and the pains inflicted on its account; but they do will the fulfillment of the ordering of divine justice in this matter, in respect to which some are subjected to pains and are allowed to fall into sin." To quote Cajetan again (Com. in IIIam, q. 46, a. 7, no. 6): "'sin displeases the blessed, but this displeasure is not sadness, because this sadness adds to the displeasure, depression, and worry that afflict the nature." See note 163 concerning what St. Thomas says in his Compend. theol., chap. 232: "Christ's higher reason fully enjoyed the beatific vision, and so He apprehended whatever pertains to the defects of others, inasmuch as this is included in divine wisdom, is fittingly ordained for some purpose, and inasmuch as anyone is permitted to sin and will be punished for the sin."

Cf. Xenia thomistica, II, 349-491, by Fr. Sadoc Szabo, O.P. De scientia beata Christi, especially the part that treats of the compatibility of the simultaneous presence in Christ of utmost joy and utmost grief, pp. 432-48.

[2180] cf. Salmanticenses, De incarnatione, disp. XVII, dub. 4, no. 47, who say: "The prevention of the overflow of joy (in the higher reason) was against the connatural consent of these parts (of the soul) and was a miracle. Hence the union of utmost joy and utmost sadness in Christ is miraculous, at least according to our previous supposition; just as proportionately is the case with the union of the state of comprehensor and wayfarer in the same Christ."

[2181] Ibid

[2182] Summa theol., IIIa, q. 46, a. 8, 2nd obj

[2183] cf. Compend. theol., chap. 232

[2184] cf. IIIa, q. 84, a. 9, ad 2.

[2185] Compend. theol., chap. 232

[2186] Acts 5. 41.

[2187] Ignatius to Romans, no. 4.

[2188] cf. IIIa, q. 46, a. 6, ad 4.

[2189] cf. De incarnat., disp. XXII, dub. 4, no. 47.

[2190] cf. IIIa, q. 15, a. 6, ad 3. See also Cajetan, Gonet, Billuart, S. Szabo, loc. cit.

[2191] John 19:30

[2192] Ibid., 16:33.

[2193] cf. La Croix de Jesus (ed. 1937).

[2194] cf. Oraison et ascension mystique de Saint Paul de la Croix, by Father Cajetan of the Name of Mary, C. P.

[2195] John 16:33.

[2196] Com. in Joan. 2:16.

[2197] Ibid

[2198] John 12:32.

[2199] Rom. 5:18f. See also St. Thomas, Com. on Romans.

[2200] cf. IIIa, q. 69, a. 3, ad 3.

[2201] Ibid., c.

[2202] John 1:29.

[2203] Acts 2:41

[2204] Ibid., 2:38.

[2205] Eph. 2:38

[2206] Col. 2:13

[2207] Luke 10:27

[2208] I John 5:4f.

[2209] John 12:31f.

[2210] Ibid., 13:27

[2211] Com. S. Thomae in Joan. 12:21.

[2212] I John 3:8

[2213] Col. 2:13 ff.

[2214] Eph. 6:10.

[2215] Apoc. 12:1f.

[2216] Ibid., 14:1f.

[2217] Ibid., 19:11-22:9

[2218] Ibid., 19:16.

[2219] Ibid., 22:13.

[2220] Dan. 2:34f.

[2221] Ibid., 2:44.

[2222] I Pet. 2 7; Ps. 117:22; Isa. 8 14.

[2223] 1 Cor. 1:23f.

[2224] Phil. 2:8f.

[2225] Exorcismus, Rit. Rom., Titulus XI, chap. 3.

[2226] Summa theol., IIIa, q. 49, a. 1

[2227] Ibid., a. 2

[2228] Matt. 12:39f.; 16:21; 17:22; 20:19; Luke 11:29; 18:33; Mark 8:31; 9:30; 10:34; 14:28; John 2:19

[2229] Acts 2:32f.; 17:31; I Cor. 15:5f.

[2230] I Cor. 15:13f.

[2231] Ibid., 15:14f.

[2232] Ibid., 15:17

[2233] Rom. 4:25.

[2234] P. G., LXI, 335.

[2235] P. G., CXXIV, 759

[2236] Ibid., CXVIII, 867.

[2237] "La resurrection du Christ devant la critique contemporaine, " Science et foi, pp. 1-6

[2238] Studia Paulina, p. 62. Father Voste gives a good explanation of St. Pauls' words: "If Christ be not risen again, your faith is vain" (I Cor. 15:14); "vain" (Greek kene) not only means without foundation, but it also signifies "empty, " which means that there is no purpose to our faith in Christ the Savior.

[2239] Rom. 5:12.

[2240] Ibid., 6:23.

[2241] Ibid., 8:10

[2242] St. Peter says: "Whom God hath raised up, having loosed the sorrows of hell as it was impossible that He should be holden by it" (Acts 2:24). This means that it was impossible for Christ to be held in the bonds of death, for then He would have been conquered by death, instead of being its conqueror

[2243] John 16:33.

[2244] Contra Gentes, Bk. IV, chap. 79; Rom. 5:17

[2245] See Appendix: The definability of the Blessed Virgin Mary's Assumption

[2246] John 6:40, 44, 55

[2247] I Cor. 15:22, 26, 54, 57.

[2248] Contra Gentes, Bk. IV, chap. 82

[2249] Apoc. 21:4.

[2250] Oration "Veneranda, " for Assumption, now abrogated.