|
Objection 1: It seems that it does not belong to a liberal man
chiefly to give. For liberality, like all other moral virtues, is
regulated by prudence. Now it seems to belong very much to prudence
that a man should keep his riches. Wherefore the Philosopher says
(Ethic. iv, 1) that "those who have not earned money, but have
received the money earned by others, spend it more liberally, because
they have not experienced the want of it." Therefore it seems that
giving does not chiefly belong to the liberal man.
Objection 2: Further, no man is sorry for what he intends chiefly
to do, nor does he cease from doing it. But a liberal man is
sometimes sorry for what he has given, nor does he give to all, as
stated in Ethic. iv, 1. Therefore it does not belong chiefly to a
liberal man to give.
Objection 3: Further, in order to accomplish what he intends
chiefly, a man employs all the ways he can. Now a liberal man is not
a beggar, as the Philosopher observes (Ethic. iv, 1); and yet
by begging he might provide himself with the means of giving to others.
Therefore it seems that he does not chiefly aim at giving.
Objection 4: Further, man is bound to look after himself rather
than others. But by spending he looks after himself, whereas by
giving he looks after others. Therefore it belongs to a liberal man to
spend rather than to give.
On the contrary, The Philosopher says (Ethic. iv, 1) that "it
belongs to a liberal man to surpass in giving."
I answer that, It is proper to a liberal man to use money. Now the
use of money consists in parting with it. For the acquisition of money
is like generation rather than use: while the keeping of money, in so
far as it is directed to facilitate the use of money, is like a habit.
Now in parting with a thing ---for instance, when we throw
something---the farther we put it away the greater the force
[virtus] employed. Hence parting with money by giving it to others
proceeds from a greater virtue than when we spend it on ourselves. But
it is proper to a virtue as such to tend to what is more perfect, since
"virtue is a kind of perfection" (Phys. vii, text. 17,18).
Therefore a liberal man is praised chiefly for giving.
Reply to Objection 1: It belongs to prudence to keep money, lest
it be stolen or spent uselessly. But to spend it usefully is not less
but more prudent than to keep it usefully: since more things have to be
considered in money's use, which is likened to movement, than in its
keeping, which is likened to rest. As to those who, having received
money that others have earned, spend it more liberally, through not
having experienced the want of it, if their inexperience is the sole
cause of their liberal expenditure they have not the virtue of
liberality. Sometimes, however, this inexperience merely removes the
impediment to liberality, so that it makes them all the more ready to
act liberally, because, not unfrequently, the fear of want that
results from the experience of want hinders those who have acquired
money from using it up by acting with liberality; as does likewise the
love they have for it as being their own effect, according to the
Philosopher (Ethic. iv, 1).
Reply to Objection 2: As stated in this and the preceding
Article, it belongs to liberality to make fitting use of money, and
consequently to give it in a fitting manner, since this is a use of
money. Again, every virtue is grieved by whatever is contrary to its
act, and avoids whatever hinders that act. Now two things are opposed
to suitable giving; namely, not giving what ought suitably to be
given, and giving something unsuitably. Wherefore the liberal man is
grieved at both: but especially at the former, since it is more
opposed to his proper act. For this reason, too, he does not give to
all: since his act would be hindered were he to give to everyone: for
he would not have the means of giving to those to whom it were fitting
for him to give.
Reply to Objection 3: Giving and receiving are related to one
another as action and passion. Now the same thing is not the principle
of both action and passion. Hence, since liberality is a principle of
giving, it does not belong to the liberal man to be ready to receive,
and still less to beg. Hence the verse:
'In this world he that wishes to be pleasing to many Should give
often, take seldom, ask never.' But he makes provision in order to
give certain things according as liberality requires; such are the
fruits of his own possessions, for he is careful about realizing them
that he may make a liberal use thereof.
Reply to Objection 4: To spend on oneself is an inclination of
nature; hence to spend money on others belongs properly to a virtue.
|
|